Page 32 - Ekonomija i Biznis_noemvri 2015.indd
P. 32

ECONOMY

                                              Goran Petreski

                                The author is Associate Professor at
                             the Faculty of Economics, “Ss. Cyril and

                                                Methodius”University

The one who lies,
also steals

Whenever we talk about       The immediate reason for this                      larger, so that the public may easily find out
the state budget, it is not                  article is the recent beginning    how many bombs and rockets are there on
so important whether                         of the procedure for Budget        an American strategic bomber, but there
the budget deficit will                      revision. Nevertheless, the topic  is no way to figure out how many people
be 3.5% or 4%, but the                       covered is not linked only with    are employed in the public administration,
key issue is what the        this budget, but it is an old song that has        what has been the construction cost for
budget actually shows        lasted for years, actually it relates to all       the new baroque-style building of the
to us. In other words, the   Macedonian budgets in general. Whenever            Ministry of Finance or what have been the
key question is: Is the      a new budget or a budget revision is being         costs for making a bronze horse or lion, the
budget really giving us a    reviewed, usually the headlines in the             numerous monuments that we find hard to
proper picture about the     media are covered with figures about the           avoid when walking around. To be honest,
activities of the state?     budget deficit, capital expenditures, etc.         lack of transparency in the answers related
                             Then, being occupied with the details, we          to money is not a characteristic only of the
                             all forget the broader picture and too easily      politicians, it seems like embedded in our
                             neglect the more essential issues. Let me be       genetic code. We all know what the wealth
                             clearer. Whenever we talk about the state          of Warren Buffet is or what the bonuses
                             budget, it is not so important whether the         paid to Citigroup managers amount to, but
                             budget deficit will be 3.5% or 4%, but the key     we may not know (except through the small
                             issue is what the budget actually shows to         talks in coffee shops) about the wealth of
                             us. In other words, the key question is: Is        Mincho or Sveto, or about the salary of Zivko
                             the budget really giving us a proper picture       and Hari.
                             about the activities of the state?
                                                                                   So, after this a bit longer digression (typical
                                It is known that the politicians are not        for professors), let us go back to our topic –
                             very inclined to accountability related            the informative value of the Macedonian
                             to how they spend the money that is not            Budget. Like all private firms, the state also
                             inherited from their fathers or grandfathers       has an obligation to keep accounting records
                             but comes from taxes that are being                that should provide a picture of its financial
                             collected from the people who work hard            condition, transactions executed in a certain
                             in ore mines, textile factories, shops, etc.       period of time, cash-flows, etc. Of course,
                             Of course, this is especially related to the       every system of recording (accounting or
                             Macedonian politicians, who, for example,          statistical) is based on certain principles and
                             in spite of the irreconcilable differences         rules; otherwise it would not be a system. In
                             and mutual intolerance, are incredibly             this regard, just as there are international
                             joined in neglecting and hiding the sources        accounting standards and standards
                             of financing of their parties and election         for financial reporting, there is also an
                             campaigns. Later on, when they capture the         international methodology that is related
                             power, this mafia style secrecy just grows         to the state finances. Hence, International

32 November 2015
   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36   37